An Emotional Christmas Letter: Gareth O'Callaghan Reaches Out to Enoch Burke

An Emotional Christmas Letter: Gareth O'Callaghan Reaches Out to Enoch Burke

Self-Improvement Dec 13, 2025

Gareth O’Callaghan has penned a soul-searching letter addressed to Enoch Burke, evoking emotions and contemplating the fundamental themes of faith, respect, and compassion. As Christmas nears, O’Callaghan’s message transcends mere religious debate, capturing the essence of a man caught in a legal dilemma. According to O’Callaghan, “You’re not in jail for your divinely-ordained views on gender ideology; you’re there because you refused to do what a judge ordered.”

A History of Contention

Since August 2022, Enoch Burke’s steadfast refusal to acknowledge a transitioning student’s preferred pronouns has sparked a firestorm of global attention. His staunch stance, drawing both criticism and support, has entrenched him in headlines and raised complex questions about religious rights versus societal inclusion.

A Personal Connection

O’Callaghan conveys a deep curiosity about Burke’s motivations. He admires Burke’s resilience but questions the balance between personal beliefs and societal norms. As Burke spends his fourth term in prison, O’Callaghan relates personal experiences of visiting a prison, describing the oppressive atmosphere and reflecting on the complex mix of conviction and compassion that defines Burke’s story.

A Call for Understanding

Describing the transgender issue as reminiscent of Ireland’s transformative divorce referendum, O’Callaghan pleads for a broader understanding and empathy. He acknowledges both personal confusion towards transgender matters and the importance of supportive environments, likening the transgender experience to imprisonment in a body that one does not identify with.

Religious Debate Versus Human Connection

Reflecting on their mutual familiarity with scripture, O’Callaghan draws parallels between archaic religious precepts and contemporary challenges, suggesting fundamentalism has limited relevance today. He writes with empathy for the teacher caught in a battle between ancient scripture and modern ethics.

A Hope for Peace

As the festive season approaches, O’Callaghan expresses a hope for Burke’s contemplation and potential change. While acknowledging the impact of his teacher’s role, he invites Burke to consider the broader implications of his actions and the lasting impact he might leave behind. “In any case, I’m often reminded that all we will ever be remembered for… is the impact we had on the people whose lives we connected with. Nothing else will matter.”

Amid a heartfelt plea for reflection, Gareth O’Callaghan’s letter transcends issues of gender and religion, reaching the core of human dignity and mutual respect.

Irish Examiner

Tags